€0.00 0

Basket

No products in the basket.

Sourdough starter: how to make it, refresh it and store it. Luca Montersino answers

In short: a sourdough starter (in Italian, lievito madre) is a dough of flour and water in which natural yeasts and lactic acid bacteria ferment on their own. You make it at home from strong flour and water, “feed” it with regular refreshments, and it’s ready when, dropped into water, it floats to the surface within 20–25 minutes and doubles in volume in 4 hours. It’s slower than fresh yeast, but it gives aroma, softness and a longer shelf life – for panettone, it’s essential.

To me, a sourdough starter is like a living thing: it needs feeding, looking after and listening to every single day. Every year I get the same questions, so I’ve gathered them here and I’ll answer them one by one.

1. What is a sourdough starter and how is it different from fresh yeast?

Fresh (baker’s) yeast is a single microorganism, selected and always the same. A sourdough starter, on the other hand, is a small community of yeasts and lactic acid bacteria that arise naturally from flour and water. That’s why it works more slowly, but it gives you aroma, a delicate acidity and doughs that stay soft for longer.

2. How do you make a sourdough starter at home?

All you need is flour, water and patience.

  1. Knead 500 g of strong type 1 flour (W 400) with 200 g of water.
  2. Leave the dough to soak in water at 26–28 °C for 48 hours.
  3. Take 500 g of this dough, add 500 g of flour and water equal to 40% of the flour weight (200 g), knead and leave at 28 °C for 24 hours.
  4. Repeat this for 3–4 days.
  5. Then refresh it every 12 hours until the cycle is complete. The starter is ready when, dropped into water, it floats to the surface within 20–25 minutes and doubles its original volume in 4 hours.

3. Stiff or liquid starter: which should you choose?

The difference is the water. A stiff starter has little water (in my refreshments, 40% of the flour weight); a liquid starter (the so-called Li.Co.Li.) has equal parts water and flour. A stiff starter gives structure and a soft, fragrant crumb, and it’s the one I use for large leavened bakes such as panettone and colomba. A liquid starter is easier to manage and is widely used for bread.

4. How often should you refresh it?

If you use it often, once a day at room temperature. If you keep it in the fridge, at least once a week. Before a big bake such as panettone, though, you need several refreshments close together to bring it to full strength.

5. How can I tell if my starter is ready?

Look at three things:

  • Volume: after a refreshment it should double in volume in about 4 hours at 26–28 °C. Another test: dropped into water, it should float to the surface within 20–25 minutes. A cross cut on the surface helps: when it opens up and almost disappears, you’re there.
  • Smell: it should smell of yoghurt, of fermented milk. If it smells of vinegar or glue, it’s too acidic.
  • Acidity: if you have a pH meter, you’re looking for a value of around 4.1. In my course I explain how to read it and how to correct it.

6. What is the “bath” and is it really necessary?

The bath is a soak in water before the refreshment: I do it for 10 minutes in water at 32 °C with 1.5 g of sugar per litre. It removes some of the acidity on the surface and makes the starter sweeter. I keep my own starter in water, because for sweet leavened bakes I want a starter that’s strong but not sour.

7. How much starter should I use instead of fresh yeast?

There’s no exact conversion, because the timings change too. As a starting point, for bread you usually use 200–250 g of refreshed starter per kilo of flour, and the rising times get several hours longer. For sweet leavened bakes you’ll find the amounts in the recipe, because yeast, sugars and fats have to be balanced together.

8. How do you store it? Can you freeze it?

In the fridge it keeps well for a week between refreshments: a stiff starter wrapped tightly in a cloth tied with string, a liquid one in a closed jar. If you’re going away for a long time you can freeze it straight after a refreshment; when you take it out again, it needs a few days of refreshments to get back into shape.

9. My starter is too sour or won’t rise: what should I do?

The cause is almost always the temperature or how often it’s refreshed. Keep it between 26 and 28 °C, refresh it more often and, if it’s very sour, give it a bath before the refreshment. A sourdough starter can almost always be saved: it just takes consistency.

10. Can you make a gluten-free sourdough starter?

Yes, starting from gluten-free flours such as rice flour. In the gluten-free colomba course I use compressed yeast, but I also explain how to adapt the recipe if you have your own gluten-free starter.

Chef’s tip: always write down the time, the temperature and how long each refreshment takes to double. Within a few days you’ll understand how your starter “thinks” – and that’s what makes the difference between a good panettone and an extraordinary one.

Want to learn it with me, step by step?

In my video courses I show you every step, with the quantities and handouts to download.

Every course with one subscription

Luca Montersino
Chef and pastry chef, the face of the Italian TV shows Peccati di Gola and È sempre mezzogiorno, author of more than 24 books and a pioneer of healthy patisserie. About me

    Comments are closed

    Luca Montersino S.r.l.
    C.O.E. SM28619

    Registered in the San Marino E-commerce Register under no. 803 for online services
    Registered in the San Marino E-commerce Register under no. 810 since 23/11/2020 for B2C sales

    Registered and operating office:
    Strada Genghe di Atto, 136
    47892 Acquaviva
    Republic of San Marino

    ©2023 Luca Montersino Srl - Credits Underscore Srl